Tinsley Square Toe Mary Jane Flat

I was very surprised by the overall good reviews. I largely order based on the reviews of others so had high hopes for these shoes. However, they are cheap appearing and very boxy. They run both wide and long only worsening the appearance. I wear a size 11, so often shoes look big or un flattering, but these were remarkably unattractive shoes at this size.

Pretty shoes but neither the 10 nor the 11 fit me right. I’ve worn Franco Sarto before and size 10 worked. But on these my big toe was pressing against the top of the shoe on both sizes.

Beautiful color and great fit! I’m learning to wear flats and these are perfect! Great with pant suit or dress!

These neutral flats fit well. They were a great addition to my work wardrobe.

I love the fit of these shoes but sadly after 2 days of wearing these the inside of my right shoe started to peel. I continued wearing them because they were so comfortable but sadly only after around 3 months I have to give them up as they are too uncomfortable to wear as the entire inside is peeling. So weird that it is only my right shoe too. My left shoe is perfectly fine.