New
Current Price $69.97
Up to 51% off.
Comparable value $125.00 to $145.00
Color: Silver Leather
Fit:True to size.
Size
Width
10 people are viewing
GET $40 OFF next purchase + 5% off every Rack purchase with a Nordstrom credit card. Terms apply. Apply Now
Details & care
Signature comfort cushioning makes this pointed-toe pump a poised 9-to-5 essential.
- 2 1/2" heel
- Contour Plus cushioned footbed
- Leather upper/synthetic lining and sole
- Imported
- Women's Shoes
- Item #5927469
Helpful info:
(video)
Size info
- True to size.
- N(narrow)=2A, M(medium)=B, W(wide)=C.
Shipping & returns
This item qualifies for free shipping on orders over $89. View Shipping & Returns Policy.
This item is returnable within 40 days by mail or to U.S. Nordstrom Rack and U.S. Nordstrom stores. All beauty items are only eligible for return in U.S. Nordstrom Rack or U.S. Nordstrom stores.
Gift options
Write a gift message at Checkout and we'll email it to the recipient when their item is delivered
Need help finding the perfect gift? We've got you covered.
Naturalizer
Naturalizer began in 1927 with a revolutionary mission: to create stylish yet comfortable shoes just for women. Known for "the shoe with the beautiful fit," the brand understands that comfortable shoes can help women move through their days energetically and live life to its fullest. Naturalizer also offers hard-to-find sizes and widths to achieve a perfect fit.
Most helpful positive review
Apr 1, 2026
Cute, comfy, and a great shoe closet staple!
I used to wonder why my mom always purchased Naturalizer heels, because she was on her feet all day as a teacher. Now I understand. I don’t wear heels often, so when I do, I need a modest heel height, cushioning, and real leather, which stretches with your feet. Upon trying these on the first time, they already felt comfortable, and I am excited to wear them more!
PumpKD
Verified purchase
Reposted from nordstrom.com
Most helpful critical review
Sept 1, 2024
One size too big
Love the look but sized one size too large and I’m regularly a size 5 or 5 1/2 and these were huge and they do not carry a size 4 or 4 1/2. There sizing is way off on all their shoes.
Lammie
Reposted from naturalizer.com
naturalizer.com response
We are sorry to hear the Everly Pumps did not fit as expected. We value your feedback and review! If you need any additional assistance, please don't hesitate to contact our Consumer Care Department. You can find our contact information here: https://www.naturalizer.com/help/faq?icid=Footer_Help_FAQ.
Customer photos
Add your photo & review
Share your photo to help other shoppers.
5 stars
63%
4 stars
11%
3 stars
15%
2 stars
4%
1 star
7%
Sort by Most Helpful
Size
Color
Width
PumpKD
Reposted from nordstrom.com
Verified purchase
Apr 1, 2026
Cute, comfy, and a great shoe closet staple!
I used to wonder why my mom always purchased Naturalizer heels, because she was on her feet all day as a teacher. Now I understand. I don’t wear heels often, so when I do, I need a modest heel height, cushioning, and real leather, which stretches with your feet. Upon trying these on the first time, they already felt comfortable, and I am excited to wear them more!
ally
Reposted from nordstrom.com
Verified purchase
Mar 26, 2026
perfect work heel
I have these in three colors now, the black, nude, and red. They are so comfy and the perfect height for work. So easy to walk in! I’ll probably pick up the silver eventually, too.
BFranke
Reposted from naturalizer.com
Mar 3, 2026
Runs very large!
I ordered this very cute pump in my european size which is 37, and according to the size chart its is a 7 US.
I was so dissapointed to discover that even if they are super comfy and very nice looking, they were almost one size too big, fell off my heel and foot .Final sale so no Returns. Ordering international (Sweden) just doesn’t seem worth it - same happened with the loafers I ordered.
Baebae
Reposted from naturalizer.com
Feb 13, 2026
Nice shoes, heel height higher than 2.1/4”
Ordered these shoes: material too shines: website said 2.1/4”: higher than that; heels are to high as well: not allowed to return or exchange.. disappointed
naturalizer.com response
Thank you for the review on the Everly Pump. We apologize for the disappointment and we have forwarded this information to the appropriate team. If you need further assistance, please don't hesitate to contact our Consumer Care Department. You can find our contact information here: https://www.naturalizer.com/help/faq?icid=Footer_Help_FAQ
LadyD7
Reposted from nordstrom.com
Verified purchase
Nov 7, 2025
I aspected the Naturalizer pump to be comfortable.
It has been 2 years since I purchased. Only worn once. Hurt my feet when worn to a banquet. Going to try the pump again. Hope with a little stretching pump is more comfortable, still very cute.
JuneBug22
Reposted from nordstrom.com
Verified purchase
Aug 18, 2025
very tight
I am a true 9.5 and these were very tight. I have skinny feet and checked to see if I ordered in Narrow, but I ordered 9.5 medium. They were extremely tight which was disappointing because it is a beautiful shoe with the perfect heel height.
Outfit Ideas For This Item
Style idea 1 Style idea 2 Style idea 3 Style idea 4 Style idea 5 Style idea 6 Style idea 7
Frequently Bought Together
See More
