SOLD OUT
This item is no longer available. Browse our recommendations for something similar.
Best Sellers
See More
Details & care
Signature comfort cushioning makes this pointed-toe pump a poised 9-to-5 essential.
- 2 1/2" heel
- Contour Plus cushioned footbed
- Leather upper/synthetic lining and sole
- Imported
- Women's Shoes
- Item #5927469
Helpful info:
(video)
Size info
- True to size.
- N(narrow)=2A, M(medium)=B, W(wide)=C.
Gift options
Write a gift message at Checkout and we'll email it to the recipient when their item is delivered
Need help finding the perfect gift? We've got you covered.
Naturalizer
Naturalizer began in 1927 with a revolutionary mission: to create stylish yet comfortable shoes just for women. Known for "the shoe with the beautiful fit," the brand understands that comfortable shoes can help women move through their days energetically and live life to its fullest. Naturalizer also offers hard-to-find sizes and widths to achieve a perfect fit.
Most helpful positive review
Jan 10, 2026
COMFORTABLE!
I wore these on a New Years Eve cruise. These are extremely comfortable, and I wore them all night walking from my cabin throughout the ship. I normally go for only a couple of brands when it comes to comfort, but these are right there at the top! These were also the perfect height for lots of walking. I definitely will be checking out their other shoes!
Tam2468
Verified purchase
Reposted from naturalizer.com
Most helpful critical review
Sept 26, 2025
Tighter than wide
Ordered my usual size, 8W. These shoes fit more like a regular width. The length was not the problem, so perhaps it was the patent leather material, but it was the second pair of Naturalizers in a Wide width that did not feel wide at all.
freemarketmaven
Verified purchase
Reposted from naturalizer.com
naturalizer.com response
We are so sorry to hear that the Everly pumps didn't fit as expected. We understand how disappointing that is. We appreciate your review and we have forwarded your comments to our design team. We hope this is helpful for others. If you have any questions or concerns, please call our Naturalizer.com Consumer Care Department at 1-888-294-1648. The Call Center hours of operation are Monday-Friday 9:00a.m.-6:00p.m. and Saturday 10:00a.m.-5:00p.m. CT. Thank you for your feedback.
Customer photos
Add your photo & review
Share your photo to help other shoppers.
5 stars
64%
4 stars
14%
3 stars
10%
2 stars
5%
1 star
7%
Sort by Most Helpful
Benzo
Reposted from naturalizer.com
Verified purchase
Jan 22, 2026
Horrible fit for those with extra wide feet
I purchased the extra wide width option as my foot has expanded greatly after pregnancy. They were definitely not extra wide width. I can barely get my foot in and they’re extremely painful. I can’t size up because then the shoe would flop off my foot so I’m screwed. I needed them for a school interview and now I have to find something I already have in my closet because these cause me so much pain.
naturalizer.com response
We are sorry to hear the Everly Pumps did not fit as expected and caused disappointment. We value your feedback and review! If you need any additional assistance, please don't hesitate to contact our Consumer Care Department. You can find our contact information here: https://www.naturalizer.com/help/faq?icid=Footer_Help_FAQ.
Tam2468
Reposted from naturalizer.com
Verified purchase
Jan 10, 2026
COMFORTABLE!
I wore these on a New Years Eve cruise. These are extremely comfortable, and I wore them all night walking from my cabin throughout the ship. I normally go for only a couple of brands when it comes to comfort, but these are right there at the top! These were also the perfect height for lots of walking. I definitely will be checking out their other shoes!
918tulsatime
Reposted from naturalizer.com
Verified purchase
Jan 2, 2026
Extra Wide and so comfortable!
I have always wanted to hear heels but I have a wide foot and could not wear heels. They are tight at 1st but now that I have worn them a few times I love them!
918tulsatime
Reposted from naturalizer.com
Verified purchase
Jan 2, 2026
Extra Wide and so comfortable!
I have always wanted to hear heels but I have a wide foot and could not wear heels. They are tight at 1st but now that I have worn them a few times I love them!
MarshaAK
Reposted from naturalizer.com
Verified purchase
Dec 23, 2025
Comfortable but fits larger than usual
I gave a 4/5 since they fit about a half size too big. Other than that a great shoe and will be returning it get a smaller size.
Mj0407
Reposted from naturalizer.com
Verified purchase
Dec 19, 2025
Great fit & comfortable
True to size and so comfortable. I teach in these all day without my feet hurting at the end of the day.
