SOLD OUT
This item is no longer available. Browse our recommendations for something similar.
Similar Styles
See More
Best Sellers
See More
Details & care
A classic almond-toe silhouette defines a go-to pump grounded with a signature N5 cushioning system for everyday comfort.
- 3 1/4" heel (size 8.5).
- Textile or leather upper/synthetic lining and sole.
- By Naturalizer; imported.
- Women's Shoes.
- Item #1168609
Helpful info:
(video)
Size info
- True to size.
- N(narrow)=2A, M(medium)=B, W(wide)=C, WW(extra wide)=D.
Gift options
Write a gift message at Checkout and we'll email it to the recipient when their item is delivered.
Need help finding the perfect gift? We've got you covered.
Naturalizer
Naturalizer began in 1927 with a revolutionary mission: to create stylish yet comfortable shoes just for women. Known for "the shoe with the beautiful fit," the brand understands that comfortable shoes can help women move through their days energetically and live life to its fullest. Naturalizer also offers hard-to-find sizes and widths to achieve a perfect fit.
Most helpful positive review
Nov 23, 2025
Are you going to restock more in size 5 in the black and beige color.
Berdie
Reposted from naturalizer.com
Most helpful critical review
May 7, 2025
WHAT HAPPENED???????
I've been buying these pumps for years for a go to work shoe. The last pair I bought had noticeably cheaper materials, flimsy and cheap sides that stretch out when I walk. I can tell a HUGE difference between these and the ones I bought a few years ago. They are uncomfortable, cheap and hard to walk in. Please do better.
Shoefetishbabe
Reposted from naturalizer.com
naturalizer.com response
We are very sorry to hear that your recent Michelle Pumps aren't the same as your older ones. We understand your concern. We appreciate your review and we have forwarded your comments to our design team. If you have any questions or concerns, please call our Naturalizer.com Consumer Care Department at 1-888-294-1648. The Call Center hours of operation are Monday-Friday 9:00a.m.-6:00p.m. and Saturday 10:00a.m.-5:00p.m. CT. Thank you for your feedback.
Customer photos
Add your photo & review
Share your photo to help other shoppers.
5 stars
67%
4 stars
19%
3 stars
7%
2 stars
3%
1 star
4%
Sort by Most Helpful
HeelSearcher
Reposted from naturalizer.com
Verified purchase
Dec 2, 2025
Searching for the perfect pair
Definitely very comfortable for the first hour and a half. I wear sneakers size 6.5 and got size 6 for these heels. It was quite troublesome trying to figure out the right size since there are no more physical stores and some major stores no longer display them. Half size down is a good fit for me.
Anyway, padding on the heel and arch were good and cushiony but wish there were more cushion on the ball of the feet. It actually feels like there's no cushion but there was no pain from my big toe after wearing the heels for 3 hours. Eventually my pinky toes would rub against the side as I walked which was the only pain after an hour and a half.
Not the perfect pair but lasted longer in comfort than other heels I have.
Berdie
Reposted from naturalizer.com
Nov 23, 2025
Are you going to restock more in size 5 in the black and beige color.
Nena20
Verified purchase
Size purchased: 8 1/2
Fit:
Small
True to size
Large
Width:
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Width purchased: Width was great not too narrow nor
Color: Black
Height: 31/2
Weight: N/a
Oct 5, 2025
Stylish shoes
These shoes were awesome, very comfortable and stylish!
Was this helpful?
JessDy
Reposted from naturalizer.com
Verified purchase
Sept 21, 2025
Comfy and cute
The most comfortable heels I’ve ever worn and they’re cute! Perfect for work.
Merriman
Verified purchase
Size purchased: 8
Fit:
Small
True to size
Large
Width:
Narrow
True to width
Wide
June 29, 2025
High heels
Cute shoes, but I returned them. Too high of a heel for me. Anyone else the heel height would not be a concern.
Was this helpful?
Afton Canyon
Reposted from naturalizer.com
Verified purchase
May 27, 2025
Style, quality workmanship
I gave this shoe 5 stars due to the style and workmanship quality. I have worn Naturalizers for years. Sadly I had to return these shoes. Since breaking my foot I realized I can now only wear certain styles by Naturalizers.