'Jungle Moc' Athletic Slip-On (Women)

I don’t know what changed, but I bought two pair in the last year and they both squeak when I walk. Same size same shoe don’t know what the difference is or what they’re doing differently very disappointed. I’ve bought these shoes for years and multiple pairs at a time. They work out great when they’re not squeaking as dog walking shoes for early mornings because their waterproof and my feet don’t get wet from the grass.

I have been buying the Jungle Moc for many years and love them! However, I recently ordered 2 pair in black and they gouge into my ankles something awful. The counter and forward curve inward very much, hence the extreme pressure just under my ankles. I'm confused as to what to do to fix this. I have 3 pair that I currently wear and none of them do this. Do I have to return them never to be able to have them wearable again? DISAPPOINTED