Skip navigation

GET $40 OFF your next purchase when you apply and get approved for a Nordstrom credit card. Restrictions apply. Apply Now

Sign In

  • All Clearance
  • Clearance Under $25

  • New Markdowns

  • Women
  • Men
  • Kids
  • Shoes
  • Bags & Accessories
  • Home
  • Beauty
  • Women

  • Clothing
  • Shoes
  • Handbags
  • Accessories
  • Jewelry
  • Beauty
  • Men

  • Clothing
  • Shoes
  • Accessories
  • Kids

  • Girls' Clothing
  • Girls' Shoes
  • Boys' Clothing
  • Boys' Shoes
  • Baby
  • Bags & Accessories

  • Shoes

  • Designer

  • Home

  • Beauty

Shop Now
  • All New & Now
  • Father's Day Gifts

  • Summer Style Essentials

  • Graduation Gifts

  • New From Our Top Brands

  • Top 100 Deals

  • Just Landed from Nordstrom

  • Linen Shop

  • Vacation & Resort

  • Women

  • Clothing
  • Shoes
  • Handbags
  • Jewelry & Watches
  • Accessories
  • Men

  • Clothing
  • Shoes
  • Accessories
  • Kids

  • Girls
  • Boys
  • Baby
  • Home

  • Beauty

  • Trending

  • Women's Bold Color
  • Women's Preppy Style
  • Women's Ruffle & Lace Details
  • Men's Baggy Jeans
  • Men's Preppy Style
  • Jelly Shoes
  • Beaded Accessories
  • Flash Events

  • Kate Spade New York Up to 60% Off
  • Tommy Bahama Up to 50% Off
  • AG Up to 60% Off
  • Just Landed: Derek Lam 10 Crosby & Ramy Brook
Father's Day Gifts
  • All Women
  • New Arrivals

  • Best Sellers

  • Summer Essentials

  • Trending: Bold Colors

  • Trending: Ruffle & Lace Details

  • Trending: Preppy Style

  • Linen Shop

  • Nordstrom Made

  • Clearance

  • Clothing

  • Activewear
  • Coats & Jackets
  • Dresses
  • Jeans & Denim
  • Jumpsuits & Rompers
  • Lingerie, Hosiery & Shapewear
  • Matching Sets
  • Pajamas & Loungewear
  • Pants & Leggings
  • Shorts
  • Skirts
  • Suits & Separates
  • Sweaters
  • Sweatshirts & Hoodies
  • Swimsuits & Cover-Ups
  • Tops
  • Plus-Size Clothing
  • Shoes

  • Athletic & Sneakers
  • Boots & Booties
  • Comfort
  • Flats
  • Heels
  • Loafers
  • Oxfords
  • Sandals
  • Slippers
  • Handbags

  • Sunglasses & Eyewear

  • Jewelry & Watches

  • Accessories

  • Beauty

  • Shop by Occasion

  • Concert & Festival
  • Graduation
  • Night Out
  • Prom
  • Vacation & Resort
  • Wear to Work
  • Wedding Guest
  • Designer

  • Contemporary

  • Young Adult

Shop Now
  • All Men
  • Father's Day Gifts

  • New Arrivals

  • Best Sellers

  • Linen Shop

  • Trending: Baggy Jeans

  • Trending: Preppy Style

  • Summer Essentials

  • Sunglasses Under $100

  • Golf Shop

  • Clearance

  • Clothing

  • Activewear
  • Blazers & Sport Coats
  • Coats & Jackets
  • Dress Shirts
  • Jeans & Denim
  • Joggers & Sweatpants
  • Lounge, Pajamas & Robes
  • Pants
  • Polo Shirts
  • Shirts
  • Shorts
  • Suits & Separates
  • Sweaters
  • Sweatshirts & Hoodies
  • Swimwear & Board Shorts
  • T-Shirts
  • Underwear & Socks
  • Shoes

  • Athletic & Sneakers
  • Boots
  • Comfort
  • Designer
  • Dress Shoes
  • Loafers & Slip-Ons
  • Oxfords & Derbys
  • Sandals & Flip-Flops
  • Slippers
  • Accessories

  • Bags & Backpacks
  • Belts & Suspenders
  • Hats
  • Sunglasses & Eyewear
  • Ties & Pocket Squares
  • Watches
  • Dresswear Shop

  • Contemporary

  • Designer

  • Young Adult

  • Big & Tall

  • Grooming & Cologne

  • Shop by Occasion

  • Concert & Festival Outfits
  • Graduation
  • Prom
  • Vacation & Resort
Shop Vacation
  • All Kids
  • New Arrivals

  • Best Sellers

  • Swim Shop

  • Vacation & Resort

  • Kids' Matching Sets

  • Kids' Value Packs

  • Trending: Ruffles & Bows

  • Summer Essentials

  • Surf & Skate for Kids

  • Active Shop

  • Sneakers Under $25

  • Clearance

  • Girls' Clothing

  • Toddler Girls (Sizes 2T-4T)
  • Little Girls (Sizes 4-6x)
  • Girls & Tweens (Sizes 7-20)
  • Girls' Accessories

  • Boys' Clothing

  • Toddler Boys (Sizes 2T-4T)
  • Boys (Sizes 4-7)
  • Boys (Sizes 8-20)
  • Boys' Accessories

  • Baby Apparel & Accessories

  • Baby Girl Clothing (0-24M)
  • Baby Boy Clothing (0-24M)
  • Unisex Baby Clothing (0-24M)
  • Baby Gear & Essentials
  • Baby Shower Gifts
  • Baby's First
  • Kids' Shoes

  • Baby & Walker Shoes
  • Toddler (Sizes 7.5-12)
  • Little Kid (Sizes 12.5-3)
  • Big Kid (Sizes 3.5-7)
  • Girls' Shoes
  • Boys' Shoes
  • Shop by Occasion

  • Graduation
  • Special Occasion
  • Vacation & Resort
  • Toys

  • Disney & Character Shop

Kids' Sneakers
  • All Shoes
  • Party Shoes

  • New Arrivals

  • Best Sellers

  • Trending: Jelly Shoes

  • Trending: Western Boots

  • Sandals Under $50

  • Contemporary Brands

  • Designer Brands

  • Golf Shoes

  • Summer Essentials

  • Clearance

  • Women's Shoes

  • Athletic & Sneakers
  • Boots
  • Booties
  • Clogs
  • Comfort
  • Flats
  • Heels
  • Loafers
  • Mules
  • Oxfords
  • Sandals
  • Slippers
  • Extended Sizes & Widths
  • Men's Shoes

  • Athletic & Sneakers
  • Boots
  • Comfort
  • Designer
  • Dress Shoes
  • Loafers & Slip-Ons
  • Oxfords & Derbys
  • Sandals & Flip-Flops
  • Slippers
  • Extended Sizes & Widths
  • Kids' Shoes

  • Baby & Walker Shoes
  • Toddler (Sizes 7.5-12)
  • Little Kid (Sizes 12.5-3)
  • Big Kid (Sizes 3.5-7)
  • Girls' Shoes
  • Boys' Shoes
  • Athletic & Sneakers
  • Boots
  • Dress
  • Sandals
  • Kids' Shoes Size Chart

  • Shoe Care & Accessories

Shop Sandals
  • All Bags & Accessories
  • New Arrivals

  • Best Sellers

  • Trending: Beaded Accessories

  • Summer Accessories

  • Travel Must-Haves

  • Designer Sunglasses Under $200

  • Handbags Under $100

  • Watches Under $200

  • Clearance

  • Women's Accessories

  • Belts
  • Hats
  • Sarongs, Caftans & Cover-Ups
  • Scarves
  • Women's Handbags

  • Backpacks
  • Bag Charms
  • Clutches & Pouches
  • Crossbody Bags
  • Shoulder Bags
  • Tote Bags
  • Wallets
  • Women's Jewelry

  • Boxed Jewelry
  • Bracelets
  • Earrings
  • Jewelry & Watch Sets
  • Necklaces
  • Rings
  • Women's Fine Jewelry

  • Bracelets
  • Earrings
  • Necklaces
  • Rings
  • Under $150
  • Men's Accessories

  • Bags & Backpacks
  • Belts & Suspenders
  • Hats
  • Jewelry & Cufflinks
  • Wallets & Card Cases
  • Sunglasses & Eyewear

  • Watches

  • Luggage & Travel

  • Carry-On
  • Checked Luggage
  • Hardside Luggage
  • Softside Luggage
  • Designer

  • Designer Handbags
  • Designer Sunglasses & Eyewear
  • Designer Watches
  • Nordstrom Made

Shop Sunglasses
  • All Beauty
  • Father's Day Cologne & Grooming Gifts

  • New Arrivals

  • Best Sellers

  • Top Rated Beauty

  • Beauty Deals Up to 60% Off

  • Beauty Under $25

  • Summer Beauty Must-Haves

  • Clearance

  • Fragrance

  • Body Mist & Hair Mist
  • Candles & Diffusers
  • Cologne
  • Designer Fragrance
  • Fragrance Gift Sets
  • Perfume
  • Roller Ball & Travel Size
  • Makeup

  • Eyes
  • Face
  • Lips
  • Tools & Brushes
  • Bath & Body

  • Skin Care

  • Cleansers
  • Eye Creams & Treatments
  • Face Mists & Toners
  • Facial Masks
  • Moisturizers
  • Serums
  • Sunscreen
  • Tools & Devices
  • Hair Care

  • Hair & Scalp Treatments
  • Hair Accessories
  • Hair Dryers & Styling Tools
  • Hairstyling Products
  • Shampoo & Conditioner
  • Textured Hair Care
  • Gifts & Sets

  • Travel & Mini Sizes

  • Designer Beauty

  • Brushes, Tools & Devices

  • Men's Grooming & Cologne

  • Oral Care

  • Nails

  • Wellness & Self-Care

  • KBeauty

  • FSA/HSA Eligible Beauty

  • Top Brands

  • Anastasia Beverly Hills
  • Burberry
  • Calvin Klein
  • Charlotte Tilbury
  • Clinique
  • Dolce & Gabbana
  • Gucci
  • Kitsch
  • L'Occitane
  • Le Monde Gourmand
  • MAC Cosmetics
  • Marc Jacobs
  • NEST New York
  • Too Faced
Shop Makeup
  • All Home
  • Father's Day Home Gifts

  • Cozy Home Shop

  • New Arrivals

  • Best Sellers

  • Home Decor Under $50

  • Home Refresh

  • Travel Must-Haves

  • Outdoor Living

  • Housewarming Gifts

  • Wedding & Engagement Gifts

  • Clearance

  • Bedding

  • Comforters & Sets
  • Duvet Covers & Inserts
  • Pillows
  • Quilts
  • Sheet Sets
  • Blankets & Throws

  • Bath

  • Bath Rugs & Mats
  • Bath Towels
  • Bathroom Decor
  • Shower Curtains
  • Home Decor

  • Candles & Diffusers
  • Decorative Accessories
  • Decorative & Throw Pillows
  • Faux Plants & Stands
  • Rugs & Doormats
  • Kitchen & Tabletop

  • Bar Accessories
  • Cookware & Bakeware
  • Cutlery & Kitchen Knives
  • Drinkware & Glassware
  • Meal Prep
  • Small Appliances
  • Luggage & Travel

  • Electronic & Tech Accessories

  • Water Bottles & Tumblers

  • Storage & Cleaning

  • Pet Accessories

  • Nordstrom Made

Shop Now
  • All Gifts
  • Top Rated Gifts

  • Graduation Gifts

  • Gift Cards

  • Father's Day Gifts

  • Top 100 Gifts
  • Golf & Active Gifts
  • Watches & Accessory Gifts
  • Cologne & Grooming Gifts
  • Tech, Lounge & Home Gifts
  • Gifts by Recipient

  • Gifts for Her
  • Gifts for Him
  • Gifts for Kids & Babies
  • Gifts for Teens
  • Gifts for the Home
  • Gifts for the One Who Has Everything
  • Gifts by Price

  • Gifts Under $25
  • Gifts Under $50
  • Gifts Under $100
  • Luxe & Designer
  • Gifts by Occasion

  • Baby Shower Gifts
  • Bridesmaid Gifts
  • Groomsmen Gifts
  • Housewarming Gifts
  • Wedding & Engagement Gifts
Father's Day Gifts
Main content
  1. Home
McGuffey Sneaker, sales video thumbnail

McGuffey Sneaker (Men)

Johnston & Murphy

Men

SOLD OUT

This item is no longer available. Browse our recommendations for something similar.

Similar Styles

  • Veja Fitz Roy Trek Sneaker
    New
    Veja
    $99.97Current Price $99.97
    $200.00Comparable value $200.00
  • adidas Chavvaria Jabbar Low Top Sneaker
    New
    adidas
    $99.97Current Price $99.97
    $160.00Comparable value $160.00
  • Sperry Crossjack Sneaker
    New
    Sperry
    $29.97Current Price $29.97
    $70.00Comparable value $70.00
  • adidas Gazelle Advantage Sneaker
    New
    adidas
    $59.97Current Price $59.97
    $100.00Comparable value $100.00
See More

Best Sellers

  • Johnston & Murphy Boswell Chukka Boot
    Johnston & Murphy
    $49.98Current Price $49.98
    (71% off)71% off.
    $175.00Comparable value $175.00
    (24)
  • Johnston & Murphy Larkin Wingtip Derby
    Johnston & Murphy
    $79.97Current Price $79.97
    (Up to 48% off)Up to 48% off.
    $149.00 – $155.00Comparable value $149.00 to $155.00
    (10)
  • Johnston & Murphy Hodges Cap Toe Oxford
    New
    Johnston & Murphy
    $79.97Current Price $79.97
    (52% off)52% off.
    $169.00Comparable value $169.00
  • Johnston & Murphy Collier Penny Loafer
    New
    Johnston & Murphy
    $79.97Current Price $79.97
    (48% off)48% off.
    $155.00Comparable value $155.00
    (1)
  • Johnston & Murphy Anders Sneaker
    New
    Johnston & Murphy
    $74.97Current Price $74.97
    (54% off)54% off.
    $165.00Comparable value $165.00
    (7)
  • Johnston & Murphy Upton Plain Toe Derby
    Johnston & Murphy
    $79.97Current Price $79.97
    (52% off)52% off.
    $169.00Comparable value $169.00
    (97)
  • Johnston & Murphy Upton Perforated Plain Toe Oxford
    Johnston & Murphy
    $89.97Current Price $89.97
    (46% off)46% off.
    $169.00Comparable value $169.00
    (10)
  • Johnston & Murphy Larkin Plain Toe Derby
    Johnston & Murphy
    $79.97Current Price $79.97
    (48% off)48% off.
    $155.00Comparable value $155.00
    (3)
  • Johnston & Murphy Hayden Plain Toe Derby Sneaker
    Johnston & Murphy
    $49.97Current Price $49.97
    (64% off)64% off.
    $139.00Comparable value $139.00
    (8)
  • Johnston & Murphy Chase Perforated Sneaker
    New
    Johnston & Murphy
    $69.97 – $79.97Current Price $69.97 to $79.97
    (Up to 51% off)Up to 51% off.
    $139.00 – $145.00Comparable value $139.00 to $145.00
    (2)
  • Johnston & Murphy Amherst 2.0 U-Throat Leather Sneaker
    Johnston & Murphy
    $69.97Current Price $69.97
    (49% off)49% off.
    $139.00Comparable value $139.00
    (129)
  • Johnston & Murphy Taylor Moc Toe Penny Loafer
    Johnston & Murphy
    $89.97Current Price $89.97
    (69% off)69% off.
    $298.00Comparable value $298.00
  • Johnston & Murphy Monaco Boat Shoe
    Johnston & Murphy
    $69.97Current Price $69.97
    (53% off)53% off.
    $149.00Comparable value $149.00
    (6)
  • Johnston & Murphy Hodges Plain Toe Oxford
    New
    Johnston & Murphy
    $79.97Current Price $79.97
    (52% off)52% off.
    $169.00Comparable value $169.00
  • Johnston & Murphy Upton Wingtip Derby
    Johnston & Murphy
    $119.97Current Price $119.97
    (29% off)29% off.
    $169.00Comparable value $169.00
    (63)
  • Johnston & Murphy Beck Penny Loafer
    New
    Johnston & Murphy
    $69.97Current Price $69.97
    (41% off)41% off.
    $119.90Comparable value $119.90
  • Johnston & Murphy Dayton Driving Penny Loafer
    Johnston & Murphy
    $89.97Current Price $89.97
    (63% off)63% off.
    $245.00Comparable value $245.00
    (9)
  • Johnston & Murphy HTS1-Luxe Waterproof Golf Shoe
    Johnston & Murphy
    $79.97Current Price $79.97
    (59% off)59% off.
    $199.00Comparable value $199.00
  • Johnston & Murphy Kinnon T-Toe Sneaker
    Johnston & Murphy
    $69.97Current Price $69.97
    (53% off)53% off.
    $149.00Comparable value $149.00
    (10)
  • Johnston & Murphy Jenkins Plain Toe Derby
    Johnston & Murphy
    $69.97Current Price $69.97
    (55% off)55% off.
    $159.00Comparable value $159.00
  • Johnston & Murphy Upton GL3 Luxe Hybrid Waterproof Golf Shoe
    Johnston & Murphy
    $79.97Current Price $79.97
    (52% off)52% off.
    $169.00Comparable value $169.00
    (29)
  • Johnston & Murphy Gibbons Wingtip Derby
    Johnston & Murphy
    $69.97Current Price $69.97
    (45% off)45% off.
    $129.00Comparable value $129.00
    (3)
  • Johnston & Murphy Hodges Plain Toe Derby
    New
    Johnston & Murphy
    $79.97Current Price $79.97
    (52% off)52% off.
    $169.00Comparable value $169.00
  • Johnston & Murphy Borland Plain Toe Derby
    Johnston & Murphy
    $69.97Current Price $69.97
    (53% off)53% off.
    $150.00Comparable value $150.00
See More

Details & care

A cool contrast sole grounds a sneaker built from lightweight materials and fitted with a padded sheepskin footbed.

  • Lace-up style
  • Leather and textile upper and lining/rubber sole
  • Imported
  • Item #5741366

Size info

  • True to size.

Gift options

Write a gift message at Checkout and we'll email it to the recipient when their item is delivered
Need help finding the perfect gift? We've got you covered.
Shop Gifts

Johnston & Murphy

Not many brands can boast what Johnston & Murphy can. Since 1850, the company has "outfitted legends, leaders and independent souls—including every U.S. president since Millard Fillmore." Known for serious quality without the serious attitude, Johnston & Murphy offers finely crafted shoes and boots for men and women, as well as quality leather accessories for men.

Reviews

(15)
4.1 out of 5
Write a Review

Most helpful positive review

Apr 30, 2022
Super Comfortable and Gorgeous
Whatever leather this is, JM hit the mark in a solid way. Out-of-the-box comfort. Very soft and supple leather. The burnishing really styles them up and can be worn with jeans or khakis.
Chad R.
Reposted from Johnston & Murphy

Most helpful critical review

June 23, 2024
Good looking shoe, hurts the foor
The Pros - good looking shoe, pairs well with everything from shorts to jeans, Khakis, and some slacks. Cons - the stitching where the tongue meets the body creates abrasion on the little toe. I took it to Europe and by the end of the first day walking, my little toe was nearly bleeding. Unfortunately, this was the only shoe I carried. The only way I could wear it for the rest of my trip was to tape up my little toe. Even with that my toe has developed a callus and it hurts. I've worn many J&M shoes but this is the first time I've had this issue.
Animesh
Reposted from Johnston & Murphy

Customer photos

Add your photo & review

Share your photo to help other shoppers.

5 stars
60%
4 stars
7%
3 stars
13%
2 stars
20%
1 star
0%
Sort by Most Helpful
Animesh
Reposted from Johnston & Murphy
June 23, 2024
Good looking shoe, hurts the foor
The Pros - good looking shoe, pairs well with everything from shorts to jeans, Khakis, and some slacks. Cons - the stitching where the tongue meets the body creates abrasion on the little toe. I took it to Europe and by the end of the first day walking, my little toe was nearly bleeding. Unfortunately, this was the only shoe I carried. The only way I could wear it for the rest of my trip was to tape up my little toe. Even with that my toe has developed a callus and it hurts. I've worn many J&M shoes but this is the first time I've had this issue.
Animesh
Reposted from Johnston & Murphy
June 17, 2024
Good looking shoe - very uncomfortable
I bought this shoe for my recent trip to Europe, thinking this will pair well with shorts, jeans, and dark khakhis, saving me the trouble of carrying multiple shoes. First the Pros. They are good looking and well-made. They lasted the 10-day trip, with over 12000 - 15000 steps a day over cobblestones and pavements, and held up well. They look good with a wide range of outfits. The Cons: They are extremely uncomfortable. The seam where the tongue is stitched to the main body rubs against the little toe. By the end of the first day of wearing them, my little toe was almost on the verge of bleeding due to abrasion. Changing socks did not help either. Unfortunately, I had carried only this pair of shoes and the only way I could wear them was after wrapping my toe in medical tape. Even with that, my toe has developed a callus. I hate to throw a new pair of shoes away but I can't wear them. I've had Johnston & Murphy shoes before but never had a problem with them. Severely disappointed with this pair.
Steve C.
Reposted from Johnston & Murphy
Oct 10, 2022
REALLY? Can't find long enough laces?
My McGuffey Lace-to Toes arrived and they are great looking shoes. The laces, however simply are NOT long enough to tie effectively. While they only need to add an additional two inches or so, it's annoying. J&M said they can't do anything about laces and I'd need to buy myself from another vendor. GREAT SERVICE, J&M!!
Luis D.
Reposted from Johnston & Murphy
Aug 17, 2022
Comfort & good quality, but...
I love the style very comfortable, but I have to agree with a previous comment. The laces also broke and J&M doesn't carry replacement laces in this style. It's a shame! oh and be aware they squeak! and OMG they are loud!
Chad R.
Reposted from Johnston & Murphy
Apr 30, 2022
Super Comfortable and Gorgeous
Whatever leather this is, JM hit the mark in a solid way. Out-of-the-box comfort. Very soft and supple leather. The burnishing really styles them up and can be worn with jeans or khakis.
millers215
Reposted from Johnston & Murphy
Aug 21, 2021
Fits wide and rough inside
I started with my usual size, tried to wear them but they were huge. Exchanged for a size smaller, fit in length but still sloppy. I was traveling and needed them or I would have just returned them. They are super rough inside and not comfortable to wear. My feet hurt after walking through the airport.
Load 6 more reviews
Download the Nordstrom Rack app.Download the Nordstrom Rack app.

Download Our App

And save big with alerts on price drops, new arrivals and more. Plus, Nordy Club members can access new app-exclusive perks!
Download Our App
Get free shipping on most orders over $89.Get free shipping on most orders over $89.

Free Shipping on Most Orders over $89

Plus, 40-day returns: by mail or free to U.S. stores.
Learn More
Apply today: get $40 off your next purchase plus an extra five percent off for cardmembers. A hand holding a credit card.Apply today: get $40 off your next purchase plus an extra five percent off for cardmembers. A hand holding a credit card.

$40 Off Your Next Purchase

Just apply and get approved for a Nordstrom credit card. Plus, get 5% off every Rack purchase when you use your credit card. Terms apply.
Apply Now
Help support Operation Warm. Two little girls smiling and wearing colorful coats.Help support Operation Warm. Two little girls smiling and wearing colorful coats.

Help Rack Help Kids

Join us in supporting Operation Warm, a nonprofit giving brand-new shoes and coats to kids.
Learn More & Donate Now

Get Rack Emails

Get the good stuff—new arrivals from Nordstrom, new markdowns, private sales and more.
Learn More
A new Rack store.A new Rack store.

New Nordstrom Rack Stores

Is your neighborhood on the list?
Find Your New Rack

You're in!

Stay tuned for the latest updates on new arrivals, special offers and more - all delivered straight to your inbox.

Privacy Policy

Get Email Updates:

Customer Service

  • Order Status
  • Guest Returns
  • Shipping & Return Policy
  • Gift Cards
  • Product Recalls
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us

About Us

  • About Our Brand
  • The Nordy Club
  • Store Locator
  • All Brands
  • Careers
  • Get Email Updates
  • Nordy Podcast
  • Store Openings

Nordstrom Rack & the Community

  • Our Impact
  • People & Culture

Nordstrom Card

  • Apply for a Nordstrom Card
  • Pay My Bill
  • Manage My Nordstrom Card

Nordstrom, Inc.

  • Nordstrom
  • HauteLook
  • Investor Relations
  • Press Releases
  • Nordstrom Media Network
Download Our App
  • Privacy
  • Your Privacy Rights
  • Terms & Conditions
  • California Supply Chains Act
  • ©2026 Nordstrom Rack
Wistia video thumbnail