Collier Penny Loafer

Silly me, thinking a company like Johnston & Murphy would have consistent sizing across their products. I've worn a men's regular width, size 12 shoe from J&M for years and have not had an issue with consistency. The sizing of this shoe is completely off. Unless you normally wear a narrow width shoe, you'll have issues with these. Sadly, I have to return these since they are unwearable.

I have lots of J&M shoes, and they never disappoint. These loafers are just what I needed for a casual shoe with jeans or shorts. They can be dressed up with some khakis for a dinner, or out by the pool on a lazy afternoon.

Just bought 3 more pairs, different colors. Great look, super comfortable....they need to make black ones.

I would have given this item 5 stars if it was not for the sizing issue. I wear 11.5 in also all shoes. However, this one fits more like size 11. Had I known, I would have bought 12 instead of my regular size 11.5. Great pair of shoes though.