Shanti Waterproof Leather Kitten Heel Boot

These shoes look nice, but the shaft is a bit too large for my legs, there is a slight squeak from the heels, and the right shoe is uncomfortable. I took a photo of the right shoe to show the hard crease, and the shaft fit. I measured the shaft circumference, and it was approximately 11". From reading the reviews, I expected these to either fit perfectly or slightly large, but they were a close fit. I don't usually have a problem with shoes being. too tight or uncomfortable. I do have a slight bunion on my right foot, but it has never caused me any pain, and I have never had a pair of shoes not fit because of it. The left shoe is fine, close fit, but it's not uncomfortable. The right shoe has a noticeable crease/ridge where my bunion is. You can see a line on the shoe even when I don't have it on, and I just took these out of the package. I could be wrong, but I feel like the right shoe is slightly defective. It just seems to pull in that area, and I've never had this problem before. I have two older pairs of Blondo booties, same size, and they were comfortable from the start, and I can wear socks with those. I can't help but think the pair of shoes I got have been returned more than once because of the fit.