SOLD OUT
This item is no longer available. Browse our recommendations for something similar.
Best Sellers
See More
Details & care
Burnished leather relaxes the polished look of a versatile cap-toe oxford handcrafted with minimalist detailing and inner goring that lets you wear it laceless.
- Lace-up style
- Leather upper, lining and sole
- Benchcrafted in Mexico
- Item #5645308
Size info
- True to size.
Gift options
Write a gift message at Checkout and we'll email it to the recipient when their item is delivered
Need help finding the perfect gift? We've got you covered.
Frye
Founded in 1863, Frye is the longest-operating shoemaker in the U.S. The company has evolved beyond shoes and boots to bags and more, driven by a "best in business" commitment. Famous for iconic craftsmanship, Frye products are versatile and durable, with timeless details and exquisite leathers that have earned them a massive following.
Reviews
(43)
3.7 out of 5
Fit: True to size
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Most helpful positive review
July 22, 2025
Beautiful
It's my second pair of these shoes, I bought the first one in the physical shop of NY. Love them, regret rhey close all the shops.
Marco A.
Reposted from The Frye Company
Most helpful critical review
Aug 21, 2024
Can't fit my foot into these bad boys.
What a strange design for a shoe. The tongue is held down by an elastic strap that makes it impossible for my foot to fit into a shoe that is my size. Returned instantly.
Matthew S.
Reposted from The Frye Company
Customer photos
Add your photo & review
Share your photo to help other shoppers.
5 stars
53%
4 stars
9%
3 stars
12%
2 stars
9%
1 star
16%
Sort by Most Helpful
Marco A.
Reposted from The Frye Company
July 22, 2025
Beautiful
It's my second pair of these shoes, I bought the first one in the physical shop of NY. Love them, regret rhey close all the shops.
OlgaKuznetcova
Verified purchase
Apr 15, 2025
great vintage looking
Perfect if you want not-so-boring-looking shoes as they look "aged" and, so to say, extraodinary
Fit: True to size
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased: 10M
Usual size: 10
Color: WALNUT
Was this helpful?
Micah L.
Reposted from The Frye Company
Mar 16, 2025
Too much marking and the grommets don’t line up with the whole for the laces.
To be honest, I have multiple pairs of Frye boots, loafers, and shoes. I’ve had previous Paul Bal Oxfords and loved them. Which is one of the biggest reasons I bought them. These were really marked down so it is what it is, but the quality is definitely not what it has been in the past. The holes for the laces don’t line up with the grommets which is really annoying. But I often wear them without laces so I’m not bothering returning them. Apart from that the bottoms definitely mark a lot more than any I’ve had in the past.
A S.
Reposted from The Frye Company
Jan 28, 2025
Paul Bal Oxford
Great shoes - very high quality leather. Well-made soles. They can’t compete with my Frye boots, but they are very good. There is a problem with the stitching on the upper of one shoe. They didn’t catch or something and the stitch loops have come out after about two or three wearings. Can that be repaired or replaced?.
Matthew S.
Reposted from The Frye Company
Aug 21, 2024
Can't fit my foot into these bad boys.
What a strange design for a shoe. The tongue is held down by an elastic strap that makes it impossible for my foot to fit into a shoe that is my size. Returned instantly.
Aaron K.
Reposted from The Frye Company
July 3, 2024
i own frye boots and
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] i own frye boots and loafer and when I held these against the same listed size, they seemd to be a size bigger. I was also very disapointed with the cost of shipping and returning the items. A complete waste of money and why I did not try a new size (I didnt want to have to continue spending money on shipping if tehy were again the wrong size).