Carlisle Penny Loafer

The shoes run big. After I ordered and received I saw the note on website that said order 1/2 size down 😕. Great price and nice shoe otherwise. I had to pay 9.95 to return them.

These are defective, at least in size 38. Literally hurt in a way that is not right, ie it is not a wrong fit, it is made wrong. Don’t buy, especially not on final sale like I did!

Have a few of these.. I love the look and comfort HOWEVER I ordered a 8.5 and the left was 8.5 and perfect but the right was marked 8.5 but was definitely a 9. Wouldn’t stay on my foot (the right side) I measured them and the right was longer. Back they went . 2 of the three of this brand just this time that I purchased had to go back for bad/mis sizing. I think it’s hit or miss. I might order another pair but I’m just not sure.

Great work shoe. Elevated and comfortable. Didn't need to stretch-out much, felt comfortable from day 1,

This is a nice looking leather shoe, but is very stiff. It hurt the sides of my feet when on.

Said to size down if you are a half size. A bit small if worn with thicker socks. Good if worn with tights.

The quality of these loafers is excellent. Good leather uppers and soles. But they are stiff and uncomfortable. They hurt my feet so I had to return.

There are really great shoes for the price. The color is true to the image for the TAN color. From the nicely padded insole (no arch support), to the look of the shoe and the upper leather used, I cannot speak highly enough about this shoe. They are a medium weight (not heavy). They are very comfortable...if you can find a size that works for you. My foot measures a true size 7 medium (US) / 37.5 (eu) / 23.5cm / 9.25" in. I wear Birkenstock in 37 med/narrow. I wear size 7 in Tory Burch sandals and 7.5 in closed toe shoes (my preference) for reference. I heard these ran long and narrow. I first bought the 7.5 thinking I could add a wool insole pad if needed. The shoes were an inch too long and I couldn't keep them on even with a wool insole pad. The width was fine for me but I had to exchange them for a size 7. The 7 was too small. My foot fit inside with barely 4mm to spare however the toe area was too narrow and rubbed against my large toe. Sadly I had to return these too. There is a substantial size difference between the sizes in length (almost an 1 inch). Depending on the shape of your toes and foot, these may work for you. While they are not narrow, they are on the slim side of medium in width. They are a beautiful and comfortable if you can find a size that works.

Beautiful shoe but runs a whole size larger. Sized down to an 8.5M per other reviews, and they were too big. Just ordered a size 8M. I normally wear a size 9M.

Beautiful shoes. Buttery soft leather and well made. I really really wanted them to fit. However, the 8 was too short in the toe box but fit fine in the heel. The 8 1/2 fit fine in the toe but slipped a lot the heel. I have normal width feet and never have problems with 8 1/2 size shoes fitting. Unfortunately, I sent both pairs back.

There is everything to love about this shoe except that it will not stay on the foot, as so many other reviewers have said. I have a wide foot, sized down a half size as the reviews recommended because it does run large, and the size 7 was comfortable in the toes because the leather is soft and giving, but the heel is ridiculously large, and no amount of determination and wishing would change that. I tried heel grips of different types, temporarily tacking them in place to wear them around the house and nothing worked. The back of the shoe is slightly too low to catch on the heel and is just cut too wide. Kork Ease, come on, who has such wide heels? It is the perfect look, but very sadly can not be worn. Listen to your reviewers please!

I love these! Originally ordered in 8.5 but exchanged for an 8 because they ran large. The leather is so luxurious, no break-in time needed! The soles are super comfortable. These are perfect for dressing up or down!