Skip navigation

FAST & FREE gift pickup at your favorite Rack. Just in time for the holidays. Learn More

Main content
  1. Home
  2. Women
  3. Shoes
  4. Loafers
Faith Penny Loafer video
(49)49

Faith Penny Loafer

Frye

Women

Current Price $64.97
58% off.
Comparable value $158.00
Color
Color: Lavender
The brand says this runs true to size.
Size
M
110 people viewing now
Select fulfillment method
GET $40 OFF next purchase + 5% off every Rack purchase with a Nordstrom credit card. Terms apply. Apply Now

Details & care

A classic penny keeper and raised heritage stitching on the moc toe lend timeless versatility and craftsmanship to this streamlined loafer made from polished leather. A glove-like fit and premium slip-resistant sole bring comfort and security to every step.

  • Leather upper and lining/leather and rubber sole
  • Imported
  • Item #10565631
  • Core Product ID 333333M835

Size info

  • The brand says this runs true to size.

Shipping & returns

This item qualifies for free shipping on orders over $89. View Shipping & Returns Policy.

Eligible Rack purchases made between 10/5/26 and 12/24/26 can be returned by 1/18/27 or 40 days after purchase—whichever is later. Online purchases: eligible items can be returned by mail or to a Nordstrom Rack or Nordstrom store. Store purchases: eligible items can be returned to a Nordstrom Rack or Nordstrom store. All returns are subject to our return policy terms.

Gift options

Write a gift message at Checkout and we'll email it to the recipient when their item is delivered
Need help finding the perfect gift? We've got you covered.
Shop Gifts

Frye

Founded in 1863, Frye is the longest-operating shoemaker in the U.S. The company has evolved beyond shoes and boots to bags and more, driven by a "best in business" commitment. Famous for iconic craftsmanship, Frye products are versatile and durable, with timeless details and exquisite leathers that have earned them a massive following.

Reviews

(49)494.7 out of 5
Write a Review
Fit: True to size
Width: True to width

Most helpful positive review

Oct 21, 2026

Super Soft

Absolutely love these loafers! The leather is incredibly soft and buttery, making them exceptionally comfortable to wear. For sizing reference, I typically wear a size 11 and ordered my usual size 11. Personally, I don’t rely too heavily on reviews when deciding what size to buy. I prefer to stick with my true size and go from there.
Alaskan27
Verified purchase
Reposted from nordstrom.com

Most helpful critical review

Apr 3, 2025

Not for me

I’ve been searching for tan loafers and came across these. They’re comfortable and quality, soft leather but not the style I was expecting. I think it’s the almond toe and flat sole that’s throwing me off, maybe something a bit chunkier. Unfortunately, will be returning these
NiYvBoo
Reposted from nordstrom.com

Customer photos

Add your photo & review

Share your photo to help other shoppers.

5 stars76%
4 stars20%
3 stars4%
2 stars0%
1 star0%
Oct 21, 2026

Super Soft

Absolutely love these loafers! The leather is incredibly soft and buttery, making them exceptionally comfortable to wear. For sizing reference, I typically wear a size 11 and ordered my usual size 11. Personally, I don’t rely too heavily on reviews when deciding what size to buy. I prefer to stick with my true size and go from there.
Reposted from nordstrom.com
Verified purchase
Alaskan27
Oct 20, 2026

Buttery soft

Definitely holds up to the Frye name. They’re comfortable from the moment you put them on. No breaking in. Excited to wear them this fall/winter.
Verified purchase
kaynani
Fit: True to size
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Width purchased:
M
Was this helpful?
Oct 19, 2026

Perfection

I have high arches and found the shoes to be perfect. Even a little loose near the heal but I will add an insert cushion..these are beautifully made and I am so happy I found them.
Reposted from nordstrom.com
Verified purchase
Tpthompson
Oct 18, 2026

Fyre Penny Loafer

Perfect fit - size is exact. Butter soft leather. All day comfort
Reposted from nordstrom.com
Verified purchase
MicRob
Oct 13, 2026

"Like Butter" is the correct description.

I was looking for a more substantial flat than a ballet and purchased these loafers after reading reviews. This shoe is perfect. Soft, not clunky styling and yes feel like slippers while looking like dress shoes but casual at the same time. No breaking in needed with the buttery leather. Frye leather never disappoints.
Reposted from nordstrom.com
Verified purchase
webshopper
Oct 13, 2026

Highlight: Comfort!

Buttery soft leather than makes this shoe so comfortable to wear everywhere. Ordered my true size 10 and it fits perfectly.
Reposted from nordstrom.com
Verified purchase
Shakybottom
Oct 7, 2026

Very nice shoes

Comfortable right out of the box, they look nice and will be a great work shoe. Seems true to size, although I have not tried with socks.
Reposted from nordstrom.com
Verified purchase
ALS1966
Sept 25, 2026

Great staple

Great staple for any wardrobe. The leather is so soft and comfortable. Can't wait to wear them for the Fall.
Reposted from nordstrom.com
Verified purchase
BayAreaAngel
Sept 10, 2026

soft leather

I’ve tried at least 10 pairs of loafers and these are among the most comfortable. On the more casual side, but dressier than a sneaker.
Reposted from nordstrom.com
Verified purchase
lbustama
Sept 6, 2026

Classic and comfortable

Perfect shoe. Comfy and flexible so no breaking in is needed. I ordered the dark brown. Perfect wearing with dark brown top and brown leopard belt
Reposted from nordstrom.com
Verified purchase
Marcia H
Aug 3, 2026

So comfortable

These are so comfortable and soft. Feel like they have been broken in already.
Reposted from nordstrom.com
Verified purchase
babo44
Aug 1, 2026

perfect

Comfortable straight out of the box. Normal size if wearing with regular socks, size down if wearing with thin socks or without socks.
Reposted from nordstrom.com
Verified purchase
dcm00

Outfit Ideas For This Item

Frequently Bought Together

See More