Stay All Day^® Eyeliner Set-$40 Value

I've tried so many other brands and this one in the waterproof formula is my favorite. I wear it early in the morning all through my workday then the gym after and it doesn't budge. Even in the summer when I sweat it stays put. Even when I've cried over the most horrible of horrible f-boys, at least my eyeliner still looks perfect. I love the precision of the felt tip and the milky consistency as it glides on my eyelids. I wish I could buy an endless supply and never have to worry about buying more because I don't think I'll ever switch brands.

It’s not my favorite. It stays on for a good amount of time (good enough for a day of virtual meetings, at least), but the application isn’t as easy or smooth as my cle de peau double ended eyeliner. I wanted to try stila because I heard it stayed on longer and is more saturated, and it does both. The cdp one is super fast to apply and doesn’t catch on my skin, but the black isn’t as saturated as I’d like and doesn’t stay on as long. The brown cdp is good, but sort of the same issue- just not as much. But the stila eyeliner- it takes so much longer to get a straight/not bumpy line that doesn’t catch on my eyelids (I’m part Asian and my eye shape isn’t quite a monolid, but it’s not a double lid either and I think they’re slightly hooded, if that helps). Since I normally do my makeup in 5-10 min, if it takes so long I can barely do anything else, idk if it’s worth it. It might work for someone else, though!