The Mylie T-Strap Flat

I have a pair of Mylie flats in leather. This pair fits completely different. I have found that ALL patent leather Madewell shoes run narrow and small. I have tried multiple styles and run into this same issue. For reference I usually take a 8M in Madewell shoes. But anything patent leather is not an option. So odd.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] It is a nice pair of shoes but the fit was weird. I have a narrow foot and it seemed tight even I ordered half size up. The front of the shoe is super narrow so beware. Overall a beautiful pair of shoes as usual with Madewell but comfort is number one for me especially for flats. Leather is beautiful but the black shoe was too shiny for me. I will stick to the Greta model with Madewell.

Agree with the other review by Sunny. Shoe is as pictured, very pretty, but I have the Greta flat and sized down half a size in that. Typically a 7.5 but purchased a 7. Tried a 7 in these too since they’re both Madewell, but they are too small/ narrow. I will try and size up to my usual size 7.5 in hopes I get more room in the toe box. I have average width feet. If you have slightly wide or wide feet at all, I don’t think these will work for you.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Beautiful, adorable, classy flat but these ran surprisingly small for me. Not only short but also narrow. The quality is spot on, as are all Madewell shoes. Love the russet color. I may reorder in hopes that going up a half size will give more width as well.