This item is returnable within 40 days by mail or to U.S. Nordstrom Rack and U.S. Nordstrom stores. All beauty items are only eligible for return in U.S. Nordstrom Rack or U.S. Nordstrom stores.
Gift options
Write a gift message at Checkout and we'll email it to the recipient when their item is delivered
Need help finding the perfect gift? We've got you covered.
Not many brands can boast what Johnston & Murphy can. Since 1850, the company has "outfitted legends, leaders and independent souls—including every U.S. president since Millard Fillmore." Known for serious quality without the serious attitude, Johnston & Murphy offers finely crafted shoes and boots for men and women, as well as quality leather accessories for men.
Thanks to all the reviewers for their honest findings regarding the fit of these shoes. I have always worn a size 7, however, the reviewers encouraged me to size down a 1/2 size and the fit is perfection. The shoes are well-made, the leather soft and moldable to the foot, pure comfort. Thank you, Nordstrom's!
Sybylla
Most helpful critical review
May 31, 2025
Sizing is off
Cute shoes but the sizing was way off so had to return.
Photoholic
Verified purchase
Customer photos
Add your photo & review
Share your photo to help other shoppers.
5 stars75%
4 stars6%
3 stars19%
2 stars0%
1 star0%
Mar 5, 2026
Beautiful shoes
Thanks to all the reviewers for their honest findings regarding the fit of these shoes. I have always worn a size 7, however, the reviewers encouraged me to size down a 1/2 size and the fit is perfection. The shoes are well-made, the leather soft and moldable to the foot, pure comfort. Thank you, Nordstrom's!
Sybylla
Nov 29, 2025
Great show. More colors please.
My favorite loafer. Comfortable and stylish with a tiny bit of lift. They look great with everything. My only wish is they come back with the beige and other colors. Please 🙏🏼
Gia
May 31, 2025
Sizing is off
Cute shoes but the sizing was way off so had to return.
Verified purchase
Photoholic
Aug 27, 2024
Cute shoe
Bought these shoes in beige. Liked them so ordered the black. I wish I would have returned them because unlike the beige, these slip off my heels! I am disappointed because I like the style of the shoe!
Verified purchase
JEI5
July 29, 2024
Weird Fit
This is a nice shoe but sizing way off - I tried a lager and smaller ridiculously off . Very disappointing
Cindy
July 27, 2024
They're good, but not great.
I purchased these to replace my favorite Sam Hubbard loafers that these are based on, which SH no longer makes (insert cry emoji). They look almost the same, but the fit and quality aren't quite there. The toe box is much more pointed than the SH shoe so its not as comfortable, and the linking is not real leather. That's the big miss for me. The shoe is very narrow along the center of the foot, and you can feel the edges of the sole pushing into your foot. I had purchased these for a trip to Paris for the Olympics, but left them at home because I know these wouldn't be comfortable with all the walking. I have walked many many miles in my SH loafers, without a single rub or pain point. I do like the tiny nailhead detail around the top of the sole. All in all, they look nice and may work for a person with a very narrow foot, but I wouldn't purchase them again.
