This shoe is quite comfortable. Though it has a pointed toe, the toes don’t feel crowded or cramped. The upper quality is great (as described made with genuine calf hair). The sole is good (i.e., durable), but not great because, unlike the upper it is not made of leather (which is reflected in the low price). So, for the money, this is a great, comfortable shoe to wear with a pair of jeans, or skirt and boyfriend shirt. The one thing I DON’T like has nothing to do with the shoe. I don’t like that the shoes are no longer being shipped in their boxes. It’s how I store all of my shoes in my closet. Given the number of the shoes I have, I can easily stack the boxes on top of each other, and see the brand, color, and style of each pair. I can’t stack excess shoes on top of one another. So, I’m stuck with trying to find a way to store these shoes without ruining their shape or soiling them. Not sure how many more shoes I’ll buy without their boxes.